Omega-3 essential fatty acids ("omega-3s")-most commonly associated with fish and fish oil-have been widely studied for their benefits for heart health.
Experts agree: include omega-3s in your heart-healthy diet; they may help your mind as well. The risk is minimal.
Mental Health Implications
The prevalence of depression in a society is inversely related to that society's consumption of fish: the more that people eat fish, the healthier the population, both physically and mentally. But studies are split when it comes to proving a link between an individual's consumption of omega-3s and lowered depression. All of the eight sources that discuss omega-3s acknowledge that there is promising evidence for omega-3s in the treatment of depression. Five of those studies recommend omega-3 supplementation for depression. Three studies do not recommend it, saying that the evidence is not conclusive enough.
Bipolar Disorder and Adjunctive Use
The same five sources state that omega-3s may have a mood stabilizing effect and help with short-term symptoms of bipolar disorder, and may be used as an adjunct to psychotropic medications, particularly antidepressants.
Other Mental Health Conditions
Experts are researching potential effects of omega-3s on:
- cognitive impairment/dementia
- perinatal and postpartum depression
- borderline personality disorder
- attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
- seasonal affective disorder
- violent and impulsive behavior
- childhood mood disorders
The evidence is slim, but these are additional reasons to consider a heart-healthy diet rich in omega-3s.
Drug Interactions & Contaminants
- Anticoagulants, like aspirin, warfarin, or heparin may interact to increase the risk of bleeding, though clinical evidence does not confirm this.
- Blood pressure medication may need to be adjusted.
- Contaminants may include mercury, PCBs, and dioxins in predatory fish (predatory fish include tuna, salmon, perch, pike, and swordfish).
- May affect blood sugar levels (if concerned, check with your doctor)
- May worsen low-density lipoprotein (LDL) aka "bad" cholesterol
- May trigger fish allergy
- May elevate levels of Vitamins A and D (in commercial supplements only)
- May cause hypervitamonosis A in rare cases when fish liver oil is used in high doses.
Side effects and drug interactions are the same as eating fish, and appear minimal. The most likely effect is indigestion, best addressed by taking omega-3s (or fish) with other food and, when taking supplements, taking smaller doses at different times of day rather than taking it all at once. Given the side effects and the likely benefits, the use of omega-3s in pregnancy and breastfeeding and in young children seems reasonable.
Vegetarians, Vegans and Plant Sources
Vegetarian and vegan diets are almost always very low in omega-3s, since fish oil is the most efficient way to obtain omega-3s. Some plant-based supplements are available, but they generally are low in the essential omega-3 elements, EPA and DHA. This requires taking a lot of capsules to get a therapeutic dose.
Promising, but not yet proven. A diet rich in small, non-predatory fish - typically about 2 meals a week - is good for almost everyone. Use of a diet rich in non-predatory fish or fish oil may prevent or moderate both depression or bipolar disorder and may be effective in stabilizing mood and enhancing the effectiveness of conventional anti-depressants. Although the evidence is preliminary, omega-3s may also serve as a neuroprotectant. Other uses being studied may encourage use of omega-3s pending development of evidence to the contrary.
Fish Is Best
Fish oil and other supplements supply omega-3s. But fish also contains vitamins, minerals, other fats, and other substances that may work with the omega-3s to protect the heart and overall health. Moreover, fish (but not fried fish), which is rich in protein and low in saturated fat, can replace less-healthful foods such as red meat. The benefits of fish far outweigh the potential risks from contaminants, especially if you eat it in moderation (two servings a week, about 8 to 12 ounces total, is the base recommendation) and vary the types of fish. Small, shorter-lived fish lower in the food chain, such as sardines and mackerel, accumulate less toxins.
- The EPA and DHA content of fish depends on the species.
- Lake Trout is the highest concentration, at 3% EPA and DHA. Atlantic salmon is almost 2%, but most fish are under 1%, meaning 100 grams of fish for each gram of omega-3s. At that rate, a therapeutic dose of 9.6 grams would take a lot of fish: up to two pounds a day. So if you are taking omega-3s as medicine, supplementation is essential.
For detailed information on Omega-3s and other treatments, download the full review.